2021 NFL quarterback tiers: Franchise guys, rising stars and stopgaps; this is the place your staff’s starter ranks

It is time as soon as once more for that annual ceremony of spring passage, the place I search to cluster NFL beginning quarterbacks into tidy little classes. It is my try and rank them, with out going 1-32. Quarterback tiers are again, as soon as once more!

My aim yearly is to attempt to challenge and consider in a manner through which the composition of these within the tiers don’t change a lot from one 12 months to the subsequent. In fact, that is far simpler mentioned than performed, as many of those franchises have been chasing QBs to no avail for years (or many years in some situations). I’m wanting on the totality of the staff across the QB, how safe the coach and GM are, the fashion of play, whether or not or not the QB himself is ascending or descending, his normal well being and diploma of happiness together with his environment, and so on.

It is an inexact science, at greatest, however an train I get pleasure from doing round this time yearly, for no matter it is price. Not aiming for any sizzling take stuff; simply my sincere evaluation of who has it higher than others at crucial place in all {of professional} sports activities. Additionally, in contrast to in some years previous I’m limiting this to the 32 QBs who can be atop a depth chart proper now and projected to begin Week 1.

So with out delaying the method any additional, here’s a take a look at my newest incarnation of the QB Tiers (I imagine that is Yr 5 of the method):

Tier 1: Bona fide franchise quarterbacks

2020: Patrick Mahomes, Lamar Jackson, Russell Wilson, Deshaun Watson, Tom Brady, Drew Brees, Aaron Rodgers, Carson Wentz, Ben Roethlisberger

2021: Mahomes, Jackson, Brady, Wilson, Rodgers, Josh Allen, Justin Herbert, Watson (I assume, if he even performs),  

Father Time is undefeated, besides in terms of Brady. He retains on successful {hardware} and his contemporaries proceed to fade or retire. And, fortunately for the NFL, an increasing crop of younger arms preserve stepping as much as doubtlessly fill the void. It is wild to suppose that within the subsequent 9 months two extra of those guys could also be altering groups, as Brady did a 12 months in the past, however Rodgers’s future in Inexperienced Bay is tenuous at greatest, Watson’s skill to play soccer once more anytime quickly is sort of unsure and Wilson may very well be elsewhere in 2022 as nicely.

Nobody took an even bigger leap ahead in 2020 than Allen, whose MVP-like play will not be a fluke (although I woulda mentioned the identical factor about Wentz a number of years again). As for Large Ben, nicely, the second half of final season was no fluke, both, and you’re going to should learn some time earlier than he resurfaces on this piece.

Tier 2: High execs, confirmed winners

2020: Matt Ryan, Matt Stafford, Dak Prescott

2021: Ryan, Stafford, Ryan Tannehill, Prescott, Baker Mayfield

This has tended to be the place youngish veterans who I imagine are top-10 abilities land … however guys who would not doubtless crack the record of greatest eight QBs on the planet any 12 months (that is Tier 1 territory). Ryan and Stafford have been right here for years and are not leaving anytime quickly, although I do imagine Stafford will actually flourish lastly with extra competent individuals round him by that group. I imagine he has been one of many least revered elite QBs for whereas now, however one gunslinger can solely accomplish that a lot.

Mayfield has now regarded the half for 2 of this three NFL seasons and is paired with the proper coach and play caller for him, and that Browns offense is loaded with weapons and boasts the most effective OL within the NFL. All of that helps and Baker took to being some extent guard as a substitute of a three-point shooter below Kevin Stefanski. Dak could have already made the leap to Tier 1 had an damage not worn out nearly all of his 2020 season. However I additionally fear about that offensive line and run sport and am not able to anoint something pertaining to the 2021 Dallas Cowboys simply but.

As for Herbert, he was nothing form of transcendent and historic in his rookie season regardless of being on a middling staff with a struggling teaching workers about to be whacked and thrown into the deep finish when a staff physician punctured Tyrod Taylor’s lung earlier than a sport, and he met each problem in a manner only a few kids ever have. And Tannehill has been nothing in need of wonderful since taking up the beginning job in Nashville in 2019.

Tier 3: Rising stars

2020: Kyler Murray, Jimmy Garoppolo

2021: Murray, Trevor Lawrence, Joe Burrow

Issues begin to get a bit tricker, typically, round these components. And I’ve been loath to place any rookie this excessive, however Lawrence has been the most effective participant in his age group going again to center faculty, and there’s no purpose to not suppose he’ll proceed that on the professional stage. I’ve huge reservations about nearly every little thing occurring with the Jaguars, nonetheless, however this child will shine. Laborious to screw up this type of expertise.

Identical with Burrow, although a horrid lack of safety behind a brutal season-ending damage that, sadly, appeared nearly predictable in the event you watched all of the empty-set drop backs a 12 months in the past. This was a posh surgical procedure and it often takes a full season again earlier than the QB is in peak type once more. This child is particular however they’d higher remove the video games through which he will get hit 10 instances or extra.

Kyler Murray’s first half of the season had him on a path to MVP consideration and a transfer to Tier 1, however main questions stay about Kliff’s Killer offense in AZ. Far too usually opposing scouts and coordinators would inform me their skill to maneuver the ball got here right down to Murray going off script and improvising, and everybody on that teaching workers and entrance workplace needs to be feeling the warmth if this staff as soon as once more fails to take a significant step to the playoffs. Working round for first downs will solely take you to this point.

Tier 4: You’ll be able to win with them

2020: Derek Carr, Tannehill, Mayfield, Kirk Cousins, Allen, Teddy Bridgewater, Philip Rivers, Tyrod Taylor, Jared Goff

2021: Cousins, Carr, Ryan Fitzpatrick, Wentz

I’ve been far too beneficiant with this designation prior to now. I am being a bit extra even handed this time round. Been burned too usually earlier than. Carr and Cousins have made their bones right here for some time. And right here they keep; each these groups proceed to have one wandering eye for different QBs and the Vikings simply took their potential alternative for Cousins within the draft. Las Vegas has been linked to Wilson and Rodgers. Keep tuned …

Fitzpatrick’s class modifications primarily based on the staff round him, however he’s now not strapped to an overtly rebuilding roster and has a monster protection behind him in Washington. WFT received that crappy division a 12 months in the past and simply would possibly accomplish that once more, and so they added some very attention-grabbing weapons on offense. I will purchase it. As for Wentz, the poor manner through which he dealt with his fast fall from grace has me considering we’ve got already seen by far the most effective from him, however Frank Reich is uniquely geared up to deal with him and is aware of him inside and outside. Colts play in an terrible division and have a good roster, so maybe Wentz can stabilize his play and curtail all of the turnovers and play KISS soccer to win the AFC South title.

Tier 5: Guys, veterans and place holders

2020: Fitzpatrick

2021: Garoppolo, Goff, Jameis Winston, Bridgewater

Not one of the guys listed above needs to be doing something however renting proper now. The 49ers drafted their subsequent QB already and Jimmy G might be dealt in 2022, whereas Goff might be laborious pressed to earn that cash in Detroit. Lions could find yourself kicking themselves for passing on Justin Fields this 12 months, and I believe Goff finally ends up being a bridge QB at greatest for them.

Winston barely received to play in New Orleans a 12 months in the past and I imagine Sean Payton will cull the most effective out of him … however he is also on a really low cost one-year deal and the Saints might be trying to improve. Perhaps they ultimately land a veteran, or draft one excessive a 12 months from now. However this seems like a cease hole. Bridgewater, a former Saint, is on the transfer once more and whereas I imagine he might be a pleasant slot in Denver, I additionally imagine that staff is deep within the QB market come 2022.

Tier 6: Good luck

2020: Mitch Trubisky

2021: Roethlisberger, Daniel Jones, Sam Darnold, Andy Dalton

I might see the Steelers experimenting with a brand new QB by midseason. Once you take that form of paycut to stay round to attempt to exit on one thing apart from the phrases of that ugly playoff loss to the Browns, chances are high issues will not get a lot better. Offensive line seems shaky at greatest. Lack of mobility a giant drawback. I simply do not see this going nicely and issues have been trending down since 2019.

Have by no means purchased in to Jones and that is make-or-break time for him now with all the brand new toys he has; and make or break time for many who chosen him. Too many fumbles for me and too excessive of expectations. Darnold has endured a lot in Gotham as nicely, and he strikes on however I fear about all of the hits he is already taken and what he is already been by. And that proprietor can have eyes for different QBs, too. This might be a real referendum on Panthers coordinator Joe Brady, and it might be too tall a activity.

Dalton will make manner for Justin Fields sooner or later, and has a pleasant future forward of him as a top-of-market back-up, however the fixed inflow of first-round QBs has phased guys like him and Flacco out.

Tier 7: The jury is out

2020: Burrow, Garnder Minshew, Darnold, Jarrett Stidham, Dwayne Haskins, Drew Lock, Jones

2021: Zach Wilson, Tua Tagovailoa, Mac Jones, Jalen Hurts

Wilson goes to finish up taking part in prior to he ought to, and I might suspect Week 1. Large leap he’s being requested to make, and he had few video games towards elite competitors in school. Tua has been below hearth because the second he was picked and his coach has gave the impression to be lukewarm about him at greatest; hardly superb for his improvement.

Hurts had some sensible flashes after taking part in far prior to anticipated final 12 months as Wentz flamed out. Has extra items round him now and the Eagles run sport will proceed to roll with him below heart as nicely. Jones was the Pats man and matches what Invoice Belichick desires and one would suppose performs just about immediately, with Cam Newton ready for use as a dynamic change-up within the pink zone and quick yardage and sure packages.


Leave a Reply